Insider-Outsider
Insider-Outsider, what do these words really mean? Everyone is an insider. The Insider Movement naively views Islam as culturally monolithic. There are numerous subcultures in the 56 Muslim nations. Shites do not mix well with Sunnis and mosques are segregated. Kurds and Arabs may have some common cultural customs but they also have their own distinct ones. Islam is not a culture as much as Christianity is not a culture. So what are we really talking about? Islam is a religio-political system. Culture and ethnicity are somehow related to Islam for groups that happen to belong to both the ethnic group and the religion of the majority of that group. Berbers in N. Africa speak Arabic and mix with Arabs a lot. Most are muslims. But go to their villages and you will discover that their cultural lifestyle is quite different than the Arabs. Cultures vary within each Muslim country.
In Iraq I worked closely with Kurds and Assyrians. Initially the first church we planted was mixed. Later on due to the clear distinctive cultural traits of each we agreed to separate the groups so they feel more “insiders” to their own ethnic group. Language was a major factor in this decision. Kurdish youth did not understand Arabic as much as their parents. I never expected a Kurd to renounce his Kurdish identity nor the Assyrian his. They kept their cultural identities but renounced their religious identity. One was Muslim the other Nestorian. They gained a new identity in Christ and his people within the nation and worldwide.
It was a sad decision to segregate the two groups. So I met with the leaders of both and agreed that the leaders and those who were interested from both churches would get together once a week to pray and share and have communion together. This is the image of the true church that Jesus died for, a multiethnic church united in Christ. This is what the Greek word Ekkelsia implies: A gathering of those called out of the kingdom of darkness into the bright light of the kingdom of Christ. (col 1:12-13) Do not confuse Islam with the subcultures of Muslim nations.
One Response to Insider-Outsider
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Take Action!
Most Recent Article:
Book: Engaging Islam

Engaging Islam, alerts Christians to the challenges and opportunities of reaching Muslims worldwide. Inspirational stories of transformation and personal testimonies will touch your heart and encourage you to engage Muslims like never before. Author Georges Houssney.Order Now!.
New Book: Chrislam: How Missionaries Are Promoting An Islamized Gospel

An in-depth look into the Insider Movement that is a must read for Missionaries, Pastors, Theologians and the layman. 400-pgs, 25 articles, available from i2 Ministries.
Comment Guidelines:
We encourage commenting on the articles. In order to facilitate this we have the following guidelines.
1. Address the issue in the article that you are commenting on.
2. Stay focused on the issue of the article
3. Each comment needs to cover one point and let us others interact with that point.
4. Comment on the interpretation of scriptures. Point out both the good points and the flaws in the interpretation.
5. Use scripture primarily to support your idea.
6. Let your comment be more about the article than on comments by others. Let us not fight each other. Let us interact with each other.
7. "Let your conversation be always full of grace, seasoned with salt, so that you may know how to answer everyone." (Colossians 4:6)
8. Please use real names. We should know who we are talking with. Pseudonyms, pen-names are not allowed.Please comment and write responsibly in a manner befitting God's glory.
Recent Posts
- Wycliffe, SIL & Frontiers Controversy In the Media
- Fact Check: Biblical Missiology’s Response To Wycliffe’s Comments On “Lost In Translation”
- Lost In Translation: Sign the Petition
- Letters from a Missionary Wife, Part 4
- Letters from a Missionary Wife, Part 3
- Jumping from the Sinking Wycliffe Ship: Why Theology Matters
- John Piper’s Church Takes a Stand on Contextualization
- Letters from a Missionary Wife, Part 2
- Holy Ambassadors
- Tottering at the Abyss: Pergamum and Thyatira’s Courtship with False Religion
- A Few Thoughts Made While Crossing a Minefield
- Letters from a Missionary Wife, Part 1
- Peacemaking Perspectives from a Peace-breaking Missionary
- Book Reviews: Allah: A Christian Response by Miroslav Volf
- INSIDER MOVEMENTS: A CRITICAL ASSESSMENT III, 2011 Atlanta, GA
- Global Church, Global Mission
- PodCast – Episode 02 – What’s in a Name?
- Is the Iranian Revival an “Insider Movement?”
- Book Review: Missiological Models in Ministry to Muslims
- “Give me____________or I die”
- Rediscovering the Revelational Church
- PodCast – Episode 01- Arab Spring
- Muslim Follower of Jesus, is this possible?
- Indigenous Believers Speak Out Against C5/Insider Movements
- Pastor Takes a Stand Against False Doctrine and Teaching
Categories
Twitter Updates
- Check out: Critique of the Christianity Today's article entitled: ‘The Son and the Crescent’ http://t.co/IT4V1f35 14 minutes ago
- Check out: Insider Movements and the Historical Approach http://t.co/rjIhAqhd 2 hours ago
- Check out: Analyzing the New Winds of Doctrine. http://t.co/cEntWdj8 4 hours ago
- Check out: “Sola Scriptura” Biblical Authority in Missions http://t.co/JPC9RIMm 6 hours ago
- Check out: Contextualizing the Culture not the Gospel http://t.co/BMf2nFJU 8 hours ago
Recent Comments
- isaacbaroi on Interview: Kevin Greeson of the Camel Method
- Wycliffe/SIL Calls Efforts to Hold them Accountable for Accuracy in Bible Translations ‘Satanic’ | Cracks in the Crescent on Fact Check: Biblical Missiology’s Response To Wycliffe’s Comments On “Lost In Translation”
- Updates from Wycliffe as well as Biblical Missiology « Christ the Truth on Wycliffe, SIL & Frontiers Controversy In the Media
- Updates from Wycliffe as well as Biblical Missiology « Christ the Truth on Lost In Translation: Sign the Petition
- Wycliffe, SIL and Frontiers are Damaging Missionary Efforts Among Muslims on Fact Check: Biblical Missiology’s Response To Wycliffe’s Comments On “Lost In Translation”
Live Blog Stats
Disclaimer
All articles and comments on this website are views of their respective writers and not necessarily of Biblical Missiology or other writers on BiblicalMissiology.Org.





Twitter
Facebook
RSS
This situation gets ludicrous at times. In West Java, some missionaries who promote insider/outsider have been saying that indigenous pastors and evangelists who use the local language, local music and arts, and local customs are not insiders because they do not also follow the Islamic customs; whereas non indigenous believers from a different culture who imitate the local people and follow Muslim customs are insiders.
The Insider Movement people get so confused and they confuse others.