Editor’s Note: The following is an excerpt from the book, The Rebuke of Islam, by W.H.T. Gairdner, commonly-known as Temple Gairdner. Though written in 1920, it is as relevant as if specifically written for current world events. 1

For Islam being intrinsically a theocracy, religion covers all the functions of the state, and by the state its infinite decrees are ideally enforced. Caesar vanishes and God is all in all: the sword of Caesar is the sword of Allah.

It is precisely this that makes Islam so stubborn a political problem in the East [i.e. Middle East] to-day. The section on Political Status is just as intrinsic a part of the Shari’a or Sacred Law as the section on Marriage or the section on Prayer, And that section says that all Moslem realms must look to the Khalifa [i.e. Caliph] as their supreme political leader and chief: that the government in every several realm must be exclusively in the hands of Moslems: that only Moslems have full citizen-rights: that members of all other faiths must be kept in humiliation and must pay tribute, and if they continue thus shall be given protection in return, but if not, “their blood and property thereby become lawful.” It is these principles (which lie at the back of the feeling of almost all Mohammedans [i.e. Muslims] and the thinking of most) that made possible the Armenian massacres. It is these which make true nationalism or true democracy so impossible in the East, and place the mutual relations of Mohammedan [i.e. Muslim] and non-Mohammedan [i.e. non-Muslim] on so unhealthy and unstable a basis. The fraternizations between the two which, under the stress of some temporary emotion, sometimes manifest themselves, prove superficial and false, and sometimes are succeeded by fierce reactions. There is no hope for the East [i.e. the Middle East] while the Shari’a remains unrepudiated, or unreached by the disintegrating forces of time.

Gairdner, W. H. T. (William Henry Temple). The Rebuke of Islam: Being the Fifth Edition, Rewritten and Revised of The Reproach of Islam (London: United Council For Missionary Education, 1920), 123-124.

  • User Ratings (2 Votes)


  1. Gairdner (1873-1928) was an Anglican missionary to Cairo from 1899-1928. He was an evangelist, musician, pastor, administrator, teacher, author, playwright, and devoted family man. Gairdner helped start the Arabic-English magazine, The Orient and the Occident, and served as one of its editors from its inception in 1905 until his death in 1928. Along with Samuel M. Zwemer, he helped to start the Cairo Study Centre for the training of missionaries and served as its principal Arabic teacher.

1 Comment

  1. Adam Simnowitz on

    Gairdner’s writings are golden. Though not evident in this excerpt, his commitment to evangelism and the Church was exemplary. I encourage readers to seek out his writings which are increasingly available on the internet.

    In addition to the Armenian massacres of the 19th and 20th centuries, we could add the violence perpetrated by the Taliban, Al-Qaida, Boko Haram, Al-Shabaab, Islamic State (a.k.a. ISIS, ISiL), Hezbollah, Iran, etc. Gairdner’s analysis about “fraternizations” between Muslim governments and non-Muslim governments being “temporary,” “superficial and false” has been recently repeated in Egypt. During the “Arab Spring,” professing Christians joined Muslims in shows of solidarity and unity. This has been followed by some of the most open and violent persecution of professing Christians in Egypt.

    The economic and social freedoms of the West, which are so attractive to the common Muslim, is due in great measure to Jesus’ teaching of the separation of religion and politics (Matthew 22:21). The sad irony is that Muslims continually point to this separation as one of the “weaknesses” of Christianity. By seeking to implement Sharia in the West, many Muslims are setting up themselves and their descendants to return to the very economic and social restrictions from which they fled.

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: