Book Review: Ministering in Honor-Shame Cultures: Biblical Foundations and Practical Essentials by Jayson Georges and Mark D. Baker

0
Publisher: IVP Academic (September 1, 2016)ISBN-10: 0830851461 / ISBN-13: 978-0830851461

Christians involved in cross-cultural missions quickly find out that their assumptions are not universal. Each culture has ideas of what is acceptable and unacceptable. To complicate matters, even within a given culture there are variations to these “norms.”  For these reasons misunderstandings and awkwardness abound — especially for newcomers to cross-cultural interactions. These experiences are usually painful, but God can use them to separate the chaff from the wheat in our lives as we experience a greater and more accurate awareness of ourselves, our culture, and the other culture(s) with which we interact.

Because of this, articles and publications that address these matters can be very helpful. I have found the following four books to be of immense value as I have spent time among people of other cultures, especially native Arabic speakers:

  • The Ugly American by Eugene Burdick and William J. Lederer 
  • Temperament and Character of the Arabs by Sania Hamady
  • The Arab Mind by Raphael Patai
  • The Closed Circle: An Interpretation of the Arabs by David Pryce-Jones

I wish that I could add the book under review to this list. The title alone would seem to hold much promise for cross-cultural ministry especially because the authors are professing evangelicals. (None of the above four books are written from an evangelical perspective).

Instead of finding valuable insights into the thinking of people from “honor-shame” cultures and sound exegesis of Scripture, I found the authors proposing a “paradigm shift” from what they define as “Western theology” to their “honor-shame” ideology. By their reliance on the cultural relativism of Cultural Anthropology, the authors redefine and reinterpret God’s Word in a way that results in “another gospel” (2 Cor 11:4; Gal 1:6).

It is my hope that the downloadable review — which includes numerous quotes from the book along with multiple Scripture references with which to compare the authors’ claims — will magnify to each reader what Jesus said to the Father on the night of His arrest, “Your word is truth” (John 17:17).

Two very helpful resources for ministry to Muslims from outstanding evangelicals are:
  • The Bible and Islam: Sharing God’s Word with a Muslim. A Basic Guide, by Bassam Michael Madany (a native Middle-Easterner), available here.
  • Sharing Your Faith With a Muslim, by Charles Marsh, available here.
For additional critiques of the authors and their “honor-shame” viewpoint see:

View Book Review as a pdf

.
Share.

About Author

Adam Simnowitz is a minister with the Assemblies of God. He lives in Dearborn, MI. He holds a M.A. from Columbia International University from their College of Intercultural Studies. His thesis is available on this website: "Muslim Idiom Translation: Assessing So-Called Scripture Translation For Muslim Audiences With A Look Into Its Origins In Eugene A. Nida's Theories Of Dynamic Equivalence And Cultural Anthropology: https://biblicalmissiology.org/2016/03/21/muslim-idiom-translation-assessing-so-called-scripture-translation-for-muslim-audiences-with-a-look-into-its-origins-in-eugene-a-nidas-theories-of-dynamic-equivalence-and-cultural-anthro/

Leave A Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: